|
|
|
Heart to Heart with Hillary
|
|
Dear
Hillary,
I need to comment on the debate between “got” and “gotten” as an American.
Firstly, language evolves and is not static and never has been. Our collection
of words that we call “English” has so many German, French and Celtic roots it
is an amalgam that to suggest there is a “British vs American” way of speaking
overlooks your Commonwealth partner Canada. Do you intend to also give language
lessons to the Australians? English was largely crafted by evolution and just
because American English is the world standard preferred business language...
speaks to the wealth of its evolution.
An apple. An orange. A tree. Note it is not “an tree.” The article “an” is used
when there is an “a” or “e” sound in the subject and makes the sentence more
musical to the ear. Now, “got on” or “gotten on” are equally correct, but one is
definitely more musical.
The bus itself was a French invention in fact and the plural is spelled in two
different ways... buses and busses. Usage in either form is interchangeable. As
you are speaking in third person with your phrase (describing someone else)
“got” and “gotten” are both past tense verbs.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/gotten?s=t
Present tense: “I am getting on a bus.”
Future tense: “I will get on a bus.”
“Purity of communication” my dear doctor Hillary Dolittle? Have you spoken to a
British person in their 20’s lately? Or worse yet have you tried to understand a
Yorkshire or Scottish person? We Americans have not massacred anything
linguistically more than you have, but the language is not frozen in stone just
because the extremely massacre prone British Empire has ended. (Including those
you performed in Canada. You can check massacres of the British Empire online.)
That said we all have phrases that bother us... “Ya know, mate?” “Good on”
Prince William for being the first British royal to work for a living flying a
helicopter. Even royalty evolves just as language must.
Robert
Dear Robert,
Dare I say thank you for the scholarly barrage sent in my direction? How we
managed to get Parisian busses into the mix, I have no idea, but then, of
course, I am not a proud American, such as you, so that probably is the reason
that you were giving the Canadians some stick.
However, if you wish to nit pick, you use “an” before any word starting with a
vowel (that’s a-e-i-o-u at last count) and not just “a” and “e” and also before
a word starting with “h” such as an hotel. Does sound better, I agree. In Thai
we use “na” as a word with no meaning, but just there to keep the words flowing.
You also seem to have a problem with “its” and “it’s”, the former shows
possession, while the latter is a contraction of “it is”. So where you wrote
“speaks to the wealth of it’s evolution” it should be “speaks to the wealth of
its evolution”. But thank you for your interest my Petal and the language
lessons which are always appreciated, and I’ll get off the bus now, if I may?
Next stop Dijon?
Dear Hillary,
You didn’t have to rearrange my name letters as she can’t read but does know I
philander, when she is away. It’s really an adult game we play as I suspect many
others do as well, “mouse can play when cat is away”! The “blossoms” I cavort
with cooperate in this game as well!
Don
Dear Don (who doesn’t need to be Nod),
So glad you don’t have to use an alias any more when you’re out
non-philandering. However, I have a new girl in my English classes who said her
husband’s name was Don. I hope it wasn’t you, My Petal. I am a bit confused too
with your “blossoms” who “cooperate in this game as well.” Do you mean to say
that they call you “Nod” as well, or what? Or are you saying you have a ‘gik’ or
two in the shadows? You men do lead some rather strange lives.
Dear Hillary,
I would like to add to your advice to Don aka Nod. I too am in a committed
relationship, and like any red blooded male I look at a sexy woman and think Be
Jazus it’s me that would like a piece of that, and that’s as far as it goes. By
saying you are in a committed relationship and then admitting you cheat shows
what a weak person you are.
You must be one who when a girl says “Hello Sexy Man” you believe them. Like the
Gaffer said to the truck driver, “Pull out Driver you’ve got your load”. (Think
about that one.)
Sean
Dear Sean,
I think you are being a very naughty boy. I want you to stay in after class and
explain all this truck driver thing to me. I think it must be something to do
with sheeting and tying that I am told all truck drivers do. Am I correct? Are
they practicing some weird form of S&M or something. However, congratulations
for keeping all that libido in check.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|