This week’s road tests are of two cars
that I would just love to sit my backside in, but the number
of “test” Maserati’s in this country tend to be few and
far between (if any)! Our ‘Down-Under’ correspondent, John
Weinthal, however, did manage to have a delirious week with
the Maserati 4.2 and an Alfa Romeo. Here are the Words from
Weinthal.
“This week has been one of those of which
memories are made. I had two great Italian cars; not supercars,
but almost practical everyday cars - one for the relatively
wealthy; the second for the truly rich.
The
Maserati 4.2 Spyder and Alfa Romeo 3.0 Spyder
“These two-seater Alfa Romeo and Maserati
convertibles, or Spyders to the Italians, are exotic,
uncompromising and great to be seen in. There are fundamental
differences between the 3 litre V6 Alfa and the 4.2 litre V8
Maserati, even though both are made by FIAT which also makes
Ferrari and Lancia.
“The 287kW Maserati is rear wheel drive.
It sets you back AUD 218,000 with a conventional six-speed
gearshift or AUD 230,000 with the clutchless manual so-called
F1-style Cambiocorsa gearbox of the test car.
“The 162kW Alfa is front-drive and costs
AUD 73,000 with no choice beyond a six-speed manual. The Alfa
is also available with a 114 kW four cylinder engine for just
over AUD50,000, and both engines are available in Spyder or
coupe Alfas.
“A luxury, genuine four-seater, Maserati
coupe with the same exotic mechanicals as the Spyder was
announced this week for AUD 203,000 as a conventional
six-speed.
“The Alfa and Maserati coupes are
marginally quicker than the Spyders because they are lighter
and more aerodynamic. They also feel a lot more rigid than the
convertibles which get mild shivers on less than perfect
surfaces.
“For a day of mixed hard, winding hill
driving and town and motorway cruising, the Maser excited with
its performance, impressed with its classy style and comfort
and assured that millionaire-for-a-day feel with its totally
confident aura. It accelerates to 100 kph in a fraction under
5 seconds - adrenalin inducing by any road car standard.
“The Maser was only the second clutchless
modern car I have driven. Like the Toyota MR2 it has steering
wheel paddles like in F1 cars instead of a gearshift. I
adapted to this with the MR2, but the truth is that the Toyota
system, which is far from perfect, works a lot better than the
Italian job. I’d opt for a conventional six-speed gearshift
for my Maserati or its sister Ferrari for driving pleasure and
even greater safety, especially when pressing on. However, it
seems that few people compare the transmissions before
purchase and the majority tick the paddle-shift box on the
Maserati order form. I sympathise with them.
“At under $75,000 the Alfa is a little
closer to the real world, and by all normal standards it is
quick. It handles well and the engine and gearbox are
brilliantly matched. To my eye, the Pininfarina styling
guaranteed this Alfa classic status from day one. At every
stop I was tempted to take yet another photo from some new
angle. This is another case of the car as art - sculpted
rather than pressed, it lifts the spirits even as it sits in
your driveway or by the kerb.
“The Alfa might also be the car which
best justifies the argument against front-wheel-drive for cars
with high performance pretensions. It’s not an argument I
generally accept. Indeed with many modern cars I defy most
drivers to discern which wheels do the driving. However, the
Alfa suffers in two ways. It has a huge turning circle which
precludes a U-Turn in most normal streets. Secondly, care is
required on any rapid take-off to hold the steering wheel
firmly to counteract marked torque steer. It is easy to spin
one or both front wheels, and fast driving in winding hill
country induces marked understeer or, as the Americans say,
push.
“But if you keep all this in mind, the
Alfa is a delight. It looks stunning. It is comfortable and -
apart from hopeless radio controls and the absence of cruise
control - it is well kitted out. This includes a couple of the
lockable storages spaces which are so necessary in a
convertible.
“The Alfa’s prime competitor is the
$74,600, 176kW rear-drive Honda S2000. Among the Honda’s
plusses is a six second up and down power hood, in contrast
with the Alfa’s snail-pace and overly complex lid. But the
Honda will only be lusted after by the true car buff while
even members of the Pedestrians’ League will love the look
of the Alfa Spyder and that, surely, is what much of this sort
of spend is about.
“This was an educational driving week - I
could suffer more classes like it.”